Recent Posts

Showing posts sorted by relevance for query SFC. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query SFC. Sort by date Show all posts

Tuesday, March 22, 2016

Quick Comment On SFC Models And Mainstream Approaches

Cullen Roche has written an introductory article on Flow of Funds approaches to economics: "Understanding Flow of Funds Accounting." He asks why (post-Keynesian) Stock-Flow Consistent (SFC) models have not caught on with the mainstream. I think this is easily explained by the buried mainstream assumption that economic models must be based on the mechanic that prices bring supply and demand into balance. The post-Keynesian SFC models (as described in my primer) call into question this role of prices. In this article, I am just commenting on why this distinction exists, and not attempting to say which is better (although long-time readers will know of my bias towards SFC models).

Friday, August 23, 2013

What are Stock-Flow Consistent (SFC) Models?

This article is a short definition of what Stock-Flow Consistent (SFC) models are. I view this class of models as being the most promising among the existing types of macroeconomic models. This article is literary, I will write others which may actually have some equations (or at least pretty charts of the output). References are given below.

Wednesday, October 26, 2016

Building A SFC Model In Python

This article demonstrates the first basic application of my Stock-Flow Consistent (SFC) models package in Python: sfc_models. The code is under construction, and needs to be extended in many directions. However, with the core functionality built, adding new analytic capabilities should be straightforward. In this article, I explain how to implement the simplest SFC model -- Model SIM ("SIMplest") -- from Chapter 3 of Godley and Lavoie's Monetary Economics. The key advantage of my library is that the user just specifies the high level description of the sectors of the economy, and the package generates the underlying equations.

Wednesday, January 25, 2017

Upcoming Projects

I just wanted to give a quick update on my projects that are underway (upcoming book, SFC models development). These projects are keeping me busy, and so I will probably not have regular posts for at least a few days.


Wednesday, April 13, 2016

Equilibrium And Steady State In SFC Models

The usage of the term "equilibrium" has become almost meaningless in economics, but this does not stop it from widespread use. It is associated with the economist Walras in classical and neo-classical ("mainstream") economics. Equilibrium has the political undertone that the economy has reached an optimal state, and everyone gets their "just desserts." Post-Keynesians tend to be allergic to the term, probably because of that political slant. If we ignore the politics, the classical notion of equilibrium can be related to the one-period solution of a stock-flow consistent (SFC) model. Meanwhile, SFC models introduce the notion of a "steady state,"  which could be thought of as a "long-term equilibrium." However, since SFC models allow for involuntary unemployment, these equilibria notions do not imply any form of "just desserts."

Sunday, April 10, 2016

Primer: Money And Debt In SFC Models

How money and debt are described in simple economic models colours economists' interpretation of real world monetary systems. My feeling is that money is somewhat superfluous in these models, but it is necessary to understand why that is the case. This article explains how money and government debt (Treasury bills) operate in the second simplest Stock-Flow Consistent (SFC) model in the textbook Monetary Economics by Godley and Lavoie -- model PC (Portfolio Choice; found in chapter 4).

Saturday, March 26, 2016

Techniques For Finding SFC Model Solutions

The advantage of standard Stock-Flow Consistent (SFC) models is their analytical tractability. Although some researchers might want to include infinite horizon utility function optimisations, there is little value added if you cannot find the solution to the model. We start off with SFC models that we can find the solution, and then we can incrementally add complexity, so long as a solution method is available. I discuss various techniques to solve these models.

Sunday, March 20, 2016

Finding The Solution In A Simple SFC Model

Stock-Flow Consistent models are the mathematical workhorse of much of modern post-Keynesian thought (including Modern Monetary Theory). These models are fairly easy to work with, but there are a lot of details in how the model solution is determined. In this article, I discuss the solution for the simplest model with government money in the textbook Monetary Economics by Godley and Lavoie -- model SIM -- although I have simplified things even further (model SIMplest?).

Wednesday, March 29, 2017

The Tricky Question Of Matching Supply And Demand In SFC Models

One of the more challenging parts of developing my stock-flow consistent (SFC) models library was the question of how to match up supply and demand in a market. I generalised a technique used in Godley and Lavoie's Monetary Economics; I am still unsure whether there is a more general technique. [Update: I added some explanatory text.]

Tuesday, November 14, 2017

"An Introduction to SFC Models Using Python" Paperback Edition Published

My latest book: An Introduction to SFC Models Using Python is now available as a paperback edition. It is currently available at (some) Amazon book stores, and will show up at other online booksellers (such as Barnes and Noble) over the coming days. Many bookstores would be able to find the book via a special order.

Book Description

Stock-Flow Consistent (SFC) models are a preferred way to present economic models in the post-Keynesian tradition. This book gives an overview of the sfc_models package, which implements SFC models in Python. The approach is novel, in that the user only specifies the high-level parameters of the economic model, and the framework generates and solves the implied equations. The framework is open source, and is aimed at both researchers and those with less experience with economic models. This book explains to researchers how to extend the sfc_models framework to implement advanced models. For those who are new to SFC models, the book explains some of the basic principles behind these models, and it is possible for the reader to run example code (which is packaged with the software online) to examine the model output.


Monday, July 22, 2013

Theme: MMT and SFC Models

This article is a list of my non-time sensitive articles on Modern Monetary Theory (MMT) and Stock-Flow Consistent models. Modern Monetary Theory is an offshoot of Stock-Flow Consistent modelling, so the distinction between them is somewhat arbitrary. I categorise my articles that are more focused on monetary operations as being MMT.

Saturday, February 25, 2017

Effect Of A Rate Hike In A SFC Model

Properties: Interest Rate For Model PC Simulation
The effects of rate hikes on the economy is an interesting subject. There is an instinctive consensus view on what a rate hike accomplishes, but the demonstration of why this should be so is much less clear. One of the entertaining properties of SFC models is that at least some of them act in a way that is opposite to the consensus.

Thursday, September 26, 2013

When Should The Budget Be Balanced?


U.S. federal budget deficit by bondeconomics

Fall is in the air in the Northern hemisphere: the kids are back at school, the leaves are starting to change colour, and we have yet another pointless debt ceiling crisis in the United States. As far as I can tell, one of the root causes of debt worries is the assumption that a government budget should be run like a household budget: it should be balanced across the cycle.

Sunday, April 23, 2017

SFC Models And Introductory MMT-Style Fiscal Analysis

The usefulness of Stock-Flow Consistent (SFC) models is that they allow us to illustrate concepts in economics without relying solely on verbal descriptions. In this article, I will discuss my interpretation of some of the ideas floating around in Modern Monetary Theory (MMT). I will note that these are my interpretations of statements made by others, illustrated by an extremely simple model. The key is that even simple models can be used to clarify our thinking.

Sunday, January 8, 2017

The Determination Financial Asset Holdings In SFC Models

This article discusses how I systematically generate the systems of equations that determines financial asset holdings within the Python sfc_models framework for Stock-Flow Consistent (SFC) models. It should be noted that despite the generality of the title, I am only discussing how I attacked the problem (the results of my technique is consistent with the literature that I have studied). The existing literature relies on the derivation of system equations by hand, and so the modelling techniques used by others are less constrained than the algorithmic equation generation I use.

Monday, October 17, 2016

SFC Models Library For Python

I have been "in the zone" for coding the last little while, and have an initial version of a Python library to analyse Stock-Flow Consistent models. I still need to work on making the package easier to install, so I will wait to give a fuller description when that is ready. Since I am supposed to be finishing a book, there are no guarantees when that will happen. (Although I expect to use this module within the following book, so the delay will not be too long.)

Wednesday, November 22, 2017

"An Introduction to SFC Models Using Python" Published

Stock-Flow Consistent (SFC) models are a preferred way to present economic models in the post-Keynesian tradition. This book gives an overview of the sfc_models package, which implements SFC models in Python. The approach is novel, in that the user only specifies the high-level parameters of the economic model, and the framework generates and solves the implied equations. The framework is open source, and is aimed at both researchers and those with less experience with economic models. This book explains to researchers how to extend the sfc_models framework to implement advanced models. For those who are new to SFC models, the book explains some of the basic principles behind these models, and it is possible for the reader to run example code (which is packaged with the software online) to examine the model output.

The book is available in ebook and paperback editions.

Sunday, April 24, 2016

Anwar Shaikh On Micro And Macro Economics


As I noted in my discussion of Anwar Shaikh's new book Capitalism: Competition, Conflict, Crises, one of the most interesting parts of the work was his discussion of how microeconomic behaviour is reflected in aggregate performance. There are fundamental constraints upon individual behaviour that result in the same aggregate patterns at the macro level. Using the currently popular buzzword, macro behaviour is emergent,  and cannot be predicted from individual behaviour with reference to the aggregate system. In my view, this is useful for macro analysts, as it means we do not waste our time obsessing about the lessons of microeconomics. For mainstream ("neoclassical") economics, this line of thinking is disastrous, as it means that entire "microfoundations project" has all the usefulness of a foundation made of sand.

Wednesday, September 7, 2016

SFC vs. DSGE (Again)

There was a recent set of articles discussing Stock-Flow Consistent (SFC) and Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium (DSGE) models; an initial article by Simon Wren-Lewis (link), which led to responses by others; I would recommend these two articles (link and link) by Ramanan.